How do we fix our rookies after Round 1 of AFL SuperCoach?

Written by Bryce Whitney (@AFLBryce) on 30 March 2017   

It’s been a tough year to pick rookies and the first round has absolutely bamboozled the SuperCoach community. A majority of players we thought were shoe-ins to be the low scorers have finished as being the higher scorers, and vice versa. Making matters worse, a lot of people would have their high scorers on the bench without a way to get them into their teams. Supercoach is a cruel game at times but it’s really important to give these rookies another game before making any rash decisions.

Let's run through some of the most notable Round 1 rookies.

Sam Powell-Pepper (135k, MID, BE: -81) – Score: 78

Powell-Pepper looks like he has been playing AFL for a long time. At 65% ownership, SPP would’ve been in a lot of starting squads and was one of the few players that didn’t disappoint. In the end, he was part of a great effort by Port to take down the Swans, clocking up 19 touches and 2 goals, just like Dan Butler. The job security is high with SPP as I think Port would be silly not to go back to the well with what has shown to work once.

Dan Butler (123k, FWD, BE: -124) – Score: 96

This bloke really showed us how he can help our teams. He dropped a surprising 96 points on Thursday night against the Blues as he sunk 2 goals and finished with 19 touches. He also had 3 tackles and 5 inside 50's. He really made an impact for the Tigers and would be very unlucky not to get at least a few more games to provide us some much-needed cash. Unfortunately, he won’t get to play against the Blues every week, so this game doesn’t mean he is a going to be an automatic starter next week.

Jarrod Pickett (123k, MID/FWD, BE: 12) – Score: 28

We can’t really blame Pickett for laying a brick directly in the middle of our forward line. The ball was at least 5 kilometers away from him at all times in Carlton’s dismal effort against the Tigers. Small forwards do have the potential to go missing more than other positions, but I suspect Pickett will still make us some good cash. Keep hold of him until he gets it going.

Mitch Hannan (117k, FWD, BE: -127) – Score: 96

Hannan was the opposite of a pre-season bolter. He flew under the radar with only 3.9% ownership and scored a fantastic 96 (also like Dan Butler, this is getting suspicious now.) He had 16 touches, 7 marks, 4 tackles and 2 goals in an exciting come from behind Melbourne victory.

Ben Ainsworth (198k, MID/FWD, BE: -49) – Score: 79

We had word that there was a late change to the Suns game against the Lions. Just like that, David Swallow was out. This opened the door Ainsworth who had 14 touches, 4 marks, 6 tackles and 2 goals. He has shown us that he really needs to be considered in our teams and if Pickett or Eddy is still struggling after round 2 we could be needing to swap them to one of Ainsworth or McGrath, who both have that lovely dual position status.

Special Mentions

Joel Smith (102k, DEF, BE: 19) – Score: 23

Dislocated shoulder early in the game and won't be playing for the foreseeable future. Trade out of your team unless you need a floating loophole.

Mitchell Hibberd (123k, MID/DEF, BE: 22) – Score: 23

3 clangers (-4 points per Clanger) and 3 free’s against (-4 points per Free Against) impacted his score by 24. So he could’ve easily been over 40. Monitor.

Andrew McGrath (211k, DEF/MID, BE: -49) – Score: 83

If he scores like this again we need to get him in before Round 3.

Brett Eddy (102k, FWD, BE: -4) – Score: 30

Eddy may be a slow burn like Pickett. Owned by 61% of the league so don’t think you’re the only one that feels the low scores. Hold.

Dan Houston (117k, DEF, BE: -79) – Score: 72

Very impressive. Thought he would score 30 and Brett Eddy would score 70. Almost wasn’t named. Houston, we don’t have a problem. Sorry… I'll see myself out.

Tom Stewart (117k, DEF, BE: -49) – Score: 57

He was a lockdown defender and did his job on the field and in our teams. Held his own when the ball was around him. Should contribute decent cash.

Like what you've read? Share it with your friends on      or